---
title: Why you WANT more unsubscribes and what a low unsubscribe rate is really telling you
description: Why a low unsubscribe rate can be a deliverability red flag, why there is no benchmark, and how to track unsubscribes by opt-in type to see what they are telling you.
---

[Skip to content](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/why-you-want-more-unsubscribes-what-a-low-unsubscribe-rate-is-really-telling-you#main-content)

**FREE WEBINAR:** Email marketing in 2027: everything you need to know

[Sign up now](https://weareastral.co.uk/webinar/email-marketing-in-2027)

![astral.](https://weareastral.co.uk/hs-fs/hubfs/astral.%20new%20logo%20no%20background%20large.png?width=500&height=200&name=astral.%20new%20logo%20no%20background%20large.png)

- Email services
  
  Show submenu for Email services 
  
    - [Email Strategy Workshops](https://weareastral.co.uk/email-strategy-workshops)
    - [Email Audit](https://weareastral.co.uk/email-audit)
    - [Deliverability Audit](https://weareastral.co.uk/email-deliverability-audit)
- Email & CRM resources
  
  Show submenu for Email & CRM resources 
  
    - [Deliverability Hub](https://weareastral.co.uk/deliverability-hub)
    - [Email & CRM Vault](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault)
    - [Email Copy & Psychology Guide](https://weareastral.co.uk/email-copy-psychology-guide)
    - [Email Design Handbook](https://weareastral.co.uk/email-design-handbook)
    - [Email Deliverability Guide](https://weareastral.co.uk/email-deliverability-guide)
    - [Email Health Check tool](https://www.emailhealthcheck.co.uk/)
    - [Deliverability Health Check tool](https://www.emaildeliverabilitycheck.co.uk/)
- [astral academy](https://weareastral.co.uk/academy)
  
  Show submenu for astral academy 
  
    - [Deliverability Certification](https://weareastral.co.uk/emaildeliverability/training)
    - [Email Design Masterclass](https://weareastral.co.uk/email-design-masterclass)
    - [Inbox Psychology Masterclass](https://weareastral.co.uk/email-psychology-masterclass)
    - [Free Deliverability Training](https://weareastral.co.uk/free-email-deliverability-training)

Open main navigation

Close main navigation

- Email services
  
  Show submenu for Email services 
  
    - [Email Strategy Workshops](https://weareastral.co.uk/email-strategy-workshops)
    - [Email Audit](https://weareastral.co.uk/email-audit)
    - [Deliverability Audit](https://weareastral.co.uk/email-deliverability-audit)
- Email & CRM resources
  
  Show submenu for Email & CRM resources 
  
    - [Deliverability Hub](https://weareastral.co.uk/deliverability-hub)
    - [Email & CRM Vault](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault)
    - [Email Copy & Psychology Guide](https://weareastral.co.uk/email-copy-psychology-guide)
    - [Email Design Handbook](https://weareastral.co.uk/email-design-handbook)
    - [Email Deliverability Guide](https://weareastral.co.uk/email-deliverability-guide)
    - [Email Health Check tool](https://www.emailhealthcheck.co.uk/)
    - [Deliverability Health Check tool](https://www.emaildeliverabilitycheck.co.uk/)
- [astral academy](https://weareastral.co.uk/academy)
  
  Show submenu for astral academy 
  
    - [Deliverability Certification](https://weareastral.co.uk/emaildeliverability/training)
    - [Email Design Masterclass](https://weareastral.co.uk/email-design-masterclass)
    - [Inbox Psychology Masterclass](https://weareastral.co.uk/email-psychology-masterclass)
    - [Free Deliverability Training](https://weareastral.co.uk/free-email-deliverability-training)
- [Work with Beth](https://weareastral.co.uk/work-with-beth)

[Work with Beth](https://weareastral.co.uk/work-with-beth)

 11/2026

# Why you WANT more unsubscribes and what a low unsubscribe rate is really telling you

![Picture of Beth O'Malley](https://app.hubspot.com/settings/avatar/2761c9d87ba551994b382ed8415ad538) [Beth O'Malley](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/author/beth-omalley)

Share: [Share this page on LinkedIn](http://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/why-you-want-more-unsubscribes-what-a-low-unsubscribe-rate-is-really-telling-you) [envelope icon](mailto:?body=https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/why-you-want-more-unsubscribes-what-a-low-unsubscribe-rate-is-really-telling-you)

[← Back to the Vault](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault)

 

Somebody puts a slide up with a 0.08% unsubscribe rate on it and the room is pleased. Well under benchmark. Audience loves us!!! (don't get your hopes up just yet lol). 

My own unsubscribe rate is well above what anybody would call a benchmark (it would make your eyes water tbf), and it is above it on purpose, because I regularly invite people to leave when I can see they are not reading. I would rather they went cleanly than sat there doing nothing, and the numbers back that up.

Unsubscribes are not a measure of how much people like you. They are a measure of whether people can see your email, whether they can find the exit, and whether the people arriving on your list ever wanted to be there. Read that way, a very low number is one of the more worrying things in your reporting.

 

## What this covers

1. Why zero is the worst number you can have.
2. The three ways somebody can leave, and why unsubscribing is the one you want.
3. Why there is no benchmark, and what to compare against instead.
4. Splitting unsubscribes by opt-in type, which is the whole point of this post.
5. The psychology, which is mostly not about you.
6. And how to invite the unsubscribe without losing anybody you wanted to keep.

 

## Before you dig in, why don't you get access to RE:markable

  RE:markable is the weekly email about emails. Dropping the latest email marketing news, updates, insights, free resources, upcoming masterclasses, webinars, and of course, a little inbox mischief. 

 Subscribe to RE:markable

 

 

# The problem with zero

## People do not unsubscribe from emails they never see

An unsubscribe requires somebody to receive your email, notice it, and act. Take away the first step and the number goes to zero while everything underneath it gets worse.

- Spam placement produces beautiful unsubscribe rates. Nobody unsubscribes from the junk folder. If your placement has quietly slipped, the first thing that improves is your unsubscribe rate, which is why it is such a dangerous number to celebrate.
- The drop to zero is the signal, not the level. If you were getting unsubscribes, you are now getting none, and nothing about your sending changed, something has changed about whether you are arriving. Treat a sudden improvement with the same suspicion as a sudden decline.
- And one combination should alarm you immediately. High volume, cold or purchased data, and almost no unsubscribes. That is not a tolerant audience. That is mail not reaching people, and it is usually the last clean reading you get before a blocklisting.

 

## Key takeaway:

*A low unsubscribe rate has two possible explanations, and only one of them is good news.*

*Either your email is wanted, or it is not being seen. The rate on its own cannot tell you which, which is why it needs reading alongside placement and complaints.*

# The three exits

## Somebody who is done with you has three options, and you should want the middle one

Option one: they report you as spam

- **The worst outcome by a distance.** A complaint is read by mailbox providers as evidence that your mail is unwanted, and it affects placement for everybody else on your list. Above 0.3% you are in serious trouble, and a healthy programme lives well under 0.1%.
- **And it is the easiest of the three.** The report button sits in the menu. Nothing loads, nothing is confirmed, and it takes care of the problem permanently from their point of view.

Option two: they unsubscribe

- **Costs you nothing except a contact you were not converting.** No reputation damage, no provider signal against you, a clean consent record, and a decision you can report on.
- **It is also a deliberate act.** Which makes it informative. Somebody chose to tell you, rather than quietly disappearing.

Option three: they do nothing at all

- **The most common, and the most expensive.** Deleting takes one swipe. Ignoring takes none. So the majority of people who are finished with you simply stop engaging and stay on your list indefinitely.
- **Which is worse than it sounds.** Providers assess you on how people respond. A growing block of permanent non-responders drags your placement down for the people who do want your email. The silent majority is the group costing you money, not the people who left.

 

# The benchmark problem

## There is no number you should be aiming for

Every benchmark article will give you a figure, usually somewhere around 0.2%, and it is close to meaningless, because unsubscribe rate is determined almost entirely by things that vary wildly between businesses.

- Your acquisition mix. A list built from newsletter sign-ups behaves nothing like one built from gated downloads and competition entries.
- Your frequency. Daily senders get more unsubscribes per subscriber and fewer per send. Comparing one of those numbers across businesses tells you nothing.
- Your category. People stay subscribed to things they need. They leave things they merely wanted once.
- Whether you ask people to leave. Which is the one nobody accounts for, and the reason my own numbers look terrible against any published figure.

### What to compare against instead

1. Yourself, over time. Direction matters, levels do not. A rate that has doubled in three months is worth investigating at any level.
2. Yourself, split by source. Which is the section below, and the most useful thing in this post.
3. Your complaint rate, as a ratio. If complaints are high relative to unsubscribes, people cannot find your unsubscribe link or do not trust it. That ratio is far more diagnostic than either number alone.
4. And your net list change. Joiners minus leavers. A programme losing 400 and gaining 900 is healthy. A programme losing 40 and gaining 50 is dying slowly with an excellent unsubscribe rate.

 

# The split that matters

## Unsubscribes by opt-in type, which almost nobody tracks

Of everything in this post, the argument I would most like people to take away is this one. An unsubscribe rate for your whole list is an average across completely different populations who joined you for completely different reasons, and averaging them destroys the only useful information in the number.

### Intentional opt-ins

- They sought you out and asked to hear from you. A newsletter sign-up, a subscribe box, somebody who replied asking to be added.
- They should almost never unsubscribe. They chose this. If they are leaving in any volume, something is wrong with what you are sending, how often you are sending it, or how far it has drifted from what they signed up for.
- Which makes this your alarm bell. A rising intentional unsubscribe rate is the most direct feedback your programme can give you, and it is buried inside your overall average where you will never see it.

### Consequential opt-ins

- They wanted something and you came attached to it. A gated download, a webinar registration, a competition entry, a ticked box at checkout.
- A high unsubscribe rate here is the system working. They wanted the guide. They did not want a relationship. And every other business has trained them to expect that handing over an email address means being marketed at indefinitely, so leaving immediately is a rational and well-earned reflex.
- Watch the speed, not just the rate. If people unsubscribe within 48 hours of a download, that is them closing a door they never meant to open. Nothing to fix. If they leave at month four, you had their attention and lost it, which is a different problem entirely.

### And the rest of the ways people arrive

- Purchasers. Who expect service communication and did not necessarily agree to marketing. A high unsubscribe rate here means you have blurred the two.
- Event and webinar attendees. Warm, specific, and often added to a general programme that has nothing to do with why they came.
- Imported or legacy data. Where a high unsubscribe rate is the least bad outcome available, and a low one usually means the complaints are going somewhere else.
- Referred or forwarded contacts. Who never opted in to anything. Treat a quick exit here as entirely reasonable.

 

## Your action:

*Add opt-in source and opt-in type as properties if you do not have them, and report unsubscribes and complaints by both.*

*You cannot do this retrospectively, which is why starting today matters more than fixing history. Within a quarter it will be the most useful report you own.*

# The psychology

## Most unsubscribes are not a verdict on your email

Marketers take unsubscribes personally, and read them as judgements on the last campaign. Usually they are about something happening in the subscriber's life that has nothing to do with you.

- They got the thing they needed. Bought the sofa, booked the holiday, finished the project, hired the agency. Their need ended, so the subscription did.
- Their circumstances changed. New job, new role, no longer the person who makes that decision, no longer in that industry. Particularly common in B2B, where a meaningful share of your list changes employer every year.
- They are overwhelmed in general. Not by you. By everything. People receive more than they can process, and periodically they clear the decks. You were in the pile when the clearing happened.
- Or something made them look. The trigger is rarely your worst email. It is often an ordinary email that arrived on the day they decided to tidy up.

### And the exit got considerably easier this year

Gmail's subscription manager lists every sender somebody receives bulk mail from, shows how often each one emails them, and lets them leave with one tap. Your frequency is now a visible, comparable number, presented at the exact moment somebody is deciding whether to keep you.

Which means two things. Some of your rise in unsubscribes is the removal of friction rather than a change in sentiment. And your sending frequency is being judged directly, by people holding a list of everybody else's frequency, so it is worth knowing what yours looks like on that screen.

[READ: The Psychology of Unsubscribing: What It Really Tells You About Your Relationship with Subscribers](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/the-psychology-of-unsubscribing)

 

## Watch out for:

*Reports of unsubscribe spikes of 200% or 300% from that feature are partly a counting problem. Gmail can log several events from a single click, including against old campaigns.*

*Count unique contacts rather than events before you conclude anything, and read the Gmail post for how to check it properly.*

# The invitation

## How to ask people to leave, and why it helps

I invite unsubscribes deliberately. Not constantly, and not apologetically, but regularly enough that anybody who has stopped caring has an easy, obvious, guilt-free way out.

1. Offer less before you offer nothing. Would you rather hear from me monthly? That recovers a proportion of people who were about to leave entirely, and it is the single highest return change you can make to a preference centre.
2. Write it as relief, not as a plea. No guilt, no we will miss you, no are you sure. Somebody who is done does not want to be negotiated with, and the resentment produced by a difficult exit is what turns an unsubscribe into a complaint.
3. Put it where somebody skimming will find it. The top of the email occasionally, not only the footer. Hiding the exit is how you collect spam reports instead.
4. Be specific about who it is for. If you have not opened anything in six months, this is a good moment to tidy up. Naming the audience gives the people who are reading permission to stay.
5. And honour it instantly. A one-click unsubscribe that keeps sending for four days is a complaint generator and a compliance problem.

The reason this works is not generosity. Everybody who leaves voluntarily is somebody who was going to drag your placement down for the rest of the list, or report you eventually. You are choosing a small visible cost over a large invisible one.

 

# The dashboard

## What to watch instead of the headline rate

- **Unsubscribes by opt-in type and source.** The one that tells you whether your acquisition or your content is the problem.
- **Time from joining to unsubscribing, by source.** Immediate exits are an acquisition story. Later exits are a relevance or frequency story.
- **Complaints relative to unsubscribes.** If complaints are rising while unsubscribes are flat, people cannot find or do not trust your exit.
- **Net list change.** Joiners minus leavers, monthly, as a trend.
- **Unsubscribes by campaign type.** Which tells you whether your promotional sends are being tolerated or resented, in a way open rate never will.
- **And the share of your list that has never engaged.** The group who have not left and never will, who are quietly doing more damage than every unsubscribe you received this year.

 

## The red flags 🚩🚩🚩:

1. Unsubscribes falling with no change to your sending. Check placement before you celebrate.
2. High volume or cold sending with almost no unsubscribes. Check your complaint rate and your blocklist status today.
3. Rising complaints with flat unsubscribes. Your exit is hidden or broken.
4. Rising intentional unsubscribes. The people who chose you are leaving, which is the only version of this that is really about your email.

 

## A quick win:

*Pull the last six months of unsubscribes and split them by where those contacts came from.*

*Most businesses find that one acquisition route accounts for the majority, and that the rest of the programme looks considerably healthier once it is separated out.*

## The conclusion

List churn is normal. People's needs end, their jobs change, their inboxes overflow, and some of them only ever wanted the download. A programme with no churn is not a programme with a devoted audience, it is usually a programme with a visibility problem and a growing population of people who have stopped reading without telling you.

So stop reporting unsubscribe rate as a measure of affection. Split it by how people arrived, watch the direction rather than the level, read it next to your complaint rate, and make the exit easy enough that nobody has to reach for the spam button instead.

And if your unsubscribes are suspiciously low, find out why before somebody puts it on a slide.

 

### Further reading from The Vault:

- [Email List Churn: What's Normal, and What Isn't](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/email-list-churn-whats-normal-and-what-isnt-and-when-should-you-stop-emailing-someone)
- [Intentional vs Consequential Opt-Ins](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/intentional-vs-consequential-opt-ins)
- [Gmail for Email Marketers: Every Feature That Decides Whether You Land](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/gmail-for-email-marketers-every-feature-that-decides-whether-your-email-lands-gets-read-or-gets-unsubscribed-from)
- [How to Clean Your Email List, Properly](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/how-to-clean-your-email-list)
- [Stop Reporting on Opens and Clicks. What to Measure Instead](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/stop-reporting-on-opens-and-clicks.-heres-what-to-measure-instead)
- [How to Build an Email Early Warning System](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/how-to-build-an-email-early-warning-system-so-you-find-out-before-it-costs-you)

 

## Like this blog? You'll love RE:markable

 RE:markable is the weekly email about emails. Dropping the latest email marketing news, updates, insights, free resources, upcoming masterclasses, webinars, and of course, a little inbox mischief.

 Subscribe to RE:markable

 

## Email, CRM and HubSpot Support

I help marketers and businesses **globally** improve, design and fix their email, CRM, and HubSpot ecosystems, from strategy through to execution.

**My services include:**

- Email marketing strategy, audits, training, workshops, and consultancy
- CRM strategy and enablement
- Full HubSpot implementations, optimisation and onboarding through my agency

If you’re looking for experienced external support (and lots of enjoyment along the way), this is where to start.

[Work with Beth](https://weareastral.co.uk/work-with-beth)

 

[← Back to the Vault](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault)

[Email Marketing](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/tag/email-marketing), [Marketing Strategy](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/tag/marketing-strategy)

## More from The Vault

## [The email footer: valuable real estate, and why the unsubscribe belongs at the top](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/the-email-footer-your-most-valuable-real-estate-and-why-the-unsubscribe-belongs-at-the-top)

![Picture of Beth O'Malley](https://app.hubspot.com/settings/avatar/2761c9d87ba551994b382ed8415ad538) [Beth O'Malley](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/author/beth-omalley)

[Read more](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/the-email-footer-your-most-valuable-real-estate-and-why-the-unsubscribe-belongs-at-the-top)

## [The Psychology of Unsubscribing: What It Really Tells You About Your Relationship with Subscribers](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/the-psychology-of-unsubscribing)

![Picture of Beth O'Malley](https://app.hubspot.com/settings/avatar/2761c9d87ba551994b382ed8415ad538) [Beth O'Malley](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/author/beth-omalley)

Here is a scene that plays out in marketing teams everywhere, probably including yours. Someone...

[Read more](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/the-psychology-of-unsubscribing)

## [Gmail for email marketers: every feature that decides whether your email lands, gets read, or gets unsubscribed from](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/gmail-for-email-marketers-every-feature-that-decides-whether-your-email-lands-gets-read-or-gets-unsubscribed-from)

![Picture of Beth O'Malley](https://app.hubspot.com/settings/avatar/2761c9d87ba551994b382ed8415ad538) [Beth O'Malley](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/author/beth-omalley)

[Read more](https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/gmail-for-email-marketers-every-feature-that-decides-whether-your-email-lands-gets-read-or-gets-unsubscribed-from)

![a. final -2](https://weareastral.co.uk/hs-fs/hubfs/a.%20final%20-2.png?width=100&height=100&name=a.%20final%20-2.png "a. final -2")

Copyright © Astral Digital ™. All Rights Reserved By Astral Digital.  
Registered company number 1460594

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Beth O'Malley",
    "url" : "https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/author/beth-omalley"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-11-17T12:47:10.565Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-11-17T12:46:57.000Z",
  "headline" : "Why you WANT more unsubscribes and what a low unsubscribe rate is really telling you",
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://weareastral.co.uk/thevault/why-you-want-more-unsubscribes-what-a-low-unsubscribe-rate-is-really-telling-you",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://weareastral.co.uk/hubfs/astral.%20new%20logo%20no%20background%20large.png"
    },
    "name" : "Astral Digital"
  }
}
```