06/2025

From Email Sender to Email Strategist: Mastering the Email Ecosystem

Before you dig in, why don't you get access to RE:markable

RE:markable is the weekly email about emails. Dropping the latest email marketing news, updates, insights, free resources, upcoming masterclasses, webinars, and of course, a little inbox mischief.

Subscribe to RE:markable

Is your email marketing mindset holding you back? You’re not alone.

The thing is, it’s not “just an email.” It’s an ecosystem.

Are you a marketer who sends emails…or an email marketer?

If you’re a marketer who’s ever had email suddenly dumped on your desk, I see you. I’ve been there, too. Thirteen years ago, I was handed “email” as part of my job — no training, no guidance, just “here’s how to pull a list, build it in the ESP, get sign-off, and hit send.”

That’s how most businesses treat email. No strategy. No planning. No optimisation. Just execution.

Before you know it, email becomes the forgotten channel. It drops to the bottom of the priority list, seen as cheap, easy, fast, and “not that important.”

Email marketing becomes a checkbox activity when you’ve got loads of other marketing tasks on your list, right?

But email marketing done well is one of the most powerful, direct and cost-effective channels you have… and most businesses are wasting it.

You can become an amazing email strategist - even whilst juggling all those other marketing plates - but first, you need to change how you think about it.

Let’s get into how to do just that.

Why email is still one of the most powerful channels

Myth: Email is a throwaway tactic.

Fact: Email is great when you do it right.

Email is:

Cheap and repeatable: It’s cheaper than any paid ad for getting your brand in front of people.
Intimate: It’s the most personal space in digital: their inbox.
High-leverage: It can drive conversions, build relationships, boost retention, and reinforce your brand.
Direct and deliberate: Unlike social scrolling, opening an email is a choice.
Foundational: Email isn’t going anywhere. It’s a digital ID. You need an email to exist online.

You might be thinking, “If email is so great, why isn’t it getting the attention it deserves, then?”.

Well, it’s because it’s misunderstood and under-credited — mindsets desperately need to change.

Why thinking like an email marketer changes everything

The problem with most people’s mindset around email marketing is that it’s too minuscule — it’s more about campaign details or hitting send.

Thinking like an email marketer means zooming out and seeing the whole email ecosystem.

So, what does that mean in tangible terms?

Strategic thinking over tactics

There’s no such thing as just “doing email”. Or at least, there shouldn’t be!

You deliver a customer experience, support multiple functions (sales, service, marketing), and reinforce brand trust.

You should approach email in a way that respects the full picture, which means understanding timing, tone, segmentation, and expectations.

Data over guesswork

In the same way that you don’t just ‘do email’, you never just throw something at the wall and see what sticks, either.

You track, test, analyse, and iterate. You understand engagement signals, attribution challenges, list hygiene, and deliverability dynamics.

Most importantly, you’re not getting bogged down by becoming obsessed with open rates — you’re interested in meaningful metrics.

Curiosity over assumptions

You’re the Sherlock Holmes of email marketing now.

Well, not quite. But you ask why constantly. Why are we sending this? Why to this group? Why now? Why email?

If you don’t have a solid answer, you pause and go back to the drawing board.

Systems thinking

You know that email doesn’t exist in a silo.

Email connects with everything, including CRM, website, ads, sales touchpoints, and support.

You think in terms of flows, automations, lifecycle journeys, and cross-channel consistency.

Continuous optimisation

No campaign is ever “done.” Testing subject lines, improving segmentation, adjusting timing, refining content — it never stops. And that’s a good thing!

The best email marketing mindset to have is that everything is a continuous process of trial and error, or more accurately, trial and improvement.

Email isn’t just a channel. It’s an ecosystem.

This mindset shift is the foundation of my PPPP™ Framework (Pillars, Pyramid, Principles, Plan), which helps marketers build sustainable, high-impact strategies rooted in data, systems, and empathy.

How to get budget for email marketing

It’s all well and good knowing that email is great, and even better knowing the mindset shift required to reap the rewards, but let’s face it — convincing leadership to invest in email is one of the biggest hurdles.

More often than not, leadership sees email as cheap, “already handled,” and low-impact.

So, how do you shift that mindset?

1. Start with the problem

Like any marketer worth their salt knows, targeting pain points is a surefire way to hammer home a point. First, you need to lay the groundwork for the issues that need to be tackled.

The problem is simple: email isn’t easy, deliverability is complex, strategy is often non-existent, attribution is murky, and most companies are winging it.

2. Agitate the pain

Now, the all-important pain points!

You really need to convey how email done badly can mean:

Low engagement = wasted effort.
Bad deliverability = invisible campaigns.
Burned audiences = lost trust and unsubscribes.
Wasted acquisition = no lifecycle = churn.

3. Highlight the opportunity

Done well, email supports every function:

Lower paid ad reliance.
More qualified leads.
Increased retention and LTV.
Better brand engagement.

Case in point: I started my newsletter just to share value, not generate leads. But after one email to fewer than 500 people, I got two leads.

The cost of inaction

You might think that simply not doing anything to or with your email marketing is better than trying and failing.

The thing is, though, if you’re not evolving your email, you’re making it obsolete.

The longer you ignore it, the harder it becomes to fix, the more your deliverability degrades, and the more you need to spend on acquisition to compensate.

Put simply, email doesn’t fix itself. Either you invest in doing it right, or you pay for it elsewhere.

How to say no when they say “just send another email”

This one is for the brave, we know! Saying “no” to more emails isn’t easy, but it is essential.

Here’s how you can do it [deep breath].

Step 1. Push back with strategy

Email isn’t about standing over your audience with a megaphone and bombarding them with updates — it’s a dialogue.

Ask:

What’s the goal of this send?
Who’s it for?
Is the timing right?
What else are they hearing from us?

Step 2. Show the risk

Every single email you send affects your sender reputation. One bad campaign could mean inbox placement drops for all future emails.

It’s essential that you convey what happens when you keep pushing:

Spam complaints.
Higher unsubscribes.
Deliverability tanking.
Sales pipelines drying up.

Example: A client refused to stop batching and blasting. We warned them, but they kept going. Boom - 5 spam complaints later, and they’re now on a 12-month redemption plan (with us guiding them).

Sometimes they have to learn by doing… though ideally, simply knowing the consequences will stop the actions that cause them!

Step 3. Reassert your role

You are the marketer. They need to trust you to do the job they hired you for.

It might not always be easy or comfortable, but stand your ground and own your strategy. You know what you’re talking about!

Wrapping it up: You can be that email marketer

Email isn’t dead, and it definitely isn’t broken.

What email needs is a transformation, and that starts with how you think (we know, we know, we’ve mentioned mindset plenty already!).

But, if you:

Treat email like a powerful system.
Understand that performance starts with deliverability and strategy, not just creative
Say no to poor sends
Make decisions rooted in insight

Then you’re already starting to think like a great email marketer!

Whether you’re running solo or part of a team, email can become one of the most powerful channels in your strategy. But it needs structure, vision, and a LOT of curiosity.

If you’ve got that, then you’re ready to stop just sending emails and to start leading with them.

Need email marketing support? I’ve got you covered!

I help marketers just like you to stop winging it and start winning with email, whether it’s strategic advice, a complete overhaul, or a simple check-up that you’re looking for.

Get in touch to find out more - I can’t wait to hear from you!

Like this blog? You'll love RE:markable