10/2025

The Data-Powered Email Playbook: Collect, Model, and Use Data to Make Email Performance Grow

Before you dig in, why don't you get access to RE:markable

RE:markable is the weekly email about emails. Dropping the latest email marketing news, updates, insights, free resources, upcoming masterclasses, webinars, and of course, a little inbox mischief.

Subscribe to RE:markable

Email without data is total, total, guessing. With the right data, collected at the right moments and wired into the right decisions, email becomes a system that tells you a story: what to say, who to send it to, when to deliver it, what not to send, and how to prove impact. Most of the answers you’re hunting for already sit in your stack, they’re just not modelled or used.

In this blog you’ll find:

First principles: what “data” actually means in email
Consequential vs Intentional opt-ins (and why this single distinction fixes a lot)
A practical data collection strategy (what, why, when, where, how)
Field schemas you can paste into your CRM/ESP
Progressive profiling
Using data for exclusions (your stealth growth and deliverability lever)
“We don’t have enough data”: exactly what to do next
Signals & scoring that predict action and inaction (with simple maths)
The deliverability link (how better data prevents reputation issues)
Measuring real impact (exec-friendly) beyond opens & clicks
Advanced plays (opt-in heat, topic telemetry, no-send windows, snooze logic, kill criteria)
Copy-paste quick starts so you can implement this week

First principles: what data means in email (and how you’ll use it)

In email, “data” is not just form fields. It’s explicit things people tell you, implicit things you infer from behaviour, context about where/when/how they arrived, and outcomes that validate whether your bets worked.

Data types (use all four)

Audience/Explicit (direct)
- Role, industry, product interest, location, consent, frequency preference, “why now?”, budget band, company size.
- Use for: eligibility, messaging angle, proof selection, cadence.
Signals/Implicit (behavioural)
- Pages viewed, depth of scroll, category affinity, calculator usage, demo/pricing views, replies, customer support tickets, returns.
- Use for: intent detection, stage moves, exclusions and throttling.
Context/Situational
- Acquisition source, offer or promise at sign-up, mailbox provider, device, timezone, opt-in type (see below).
- Use for: expectation management, welcome design, provider-aware sending, send windows.
Outcomes/Results
- Time to first meaningful action, conversion rate by cohort/segment, assisted revenue, pipeline influence, retention, unsubscribe rate (neutral for deliverability), spam complaints (critical).
- Use for: proving impact, cutting poor topics, justifying exclusions and SLT reporting.

Rule of application: audience/signal/context decides who/what/when; outcome decides keep/change/stop.

The data collection strategy

A data collection strategy is a deliberate plan for what you’ll learn about people, why it matters, when/where you’ll ask for it, and how that information will actually change the emails you send. It’s not “let’s add another field to the form.” It’s deciding which pieces of information will unlock better timing, smarter exclusions, more relevant messages and proof that email is doing something useful.

Think of it like this: your email programme makes a promise at the point of entry (“we’ll help you do X”), and your data collection strategy is how you keep that promise at scale.

Why it matters (beyond “personalisation”)

It shapes the journey. If you know WHY someone signed up (“need help now” vs “just learning”), you can choose a completely different rhythm, content arc and CTA.
It protects deliverability. Data helps you exclude the wrong message at the wrong time (new subscribers shouldn’t get a promo blast or 'book a call' on day two).
It increases signal quality. Asking for motivation/intent gives you meaningful signals (what to send) instead of vanity facts (what to store).
It reduces waste. You stop guessing topics, stop sending to the wrong people, and stop training mailbox filters that your messages are ignorable.

The big distinction you must honour: Consequential vs Intentional

Not all subscribers are equal.

Consequential opt-ins happen as a by-product of something else (B2C: checkout tick box or discount pop-up; B2B: enquiry form, event signup, gated content). They didn’t come for “ongoing emails” — they came for a thing. You have to earn a second, invisible opt-in (continued engagement).
Intentional opt-ins are people actively asking for inbox value (newsletter, mini-course, waitlist). They’re warmer by default and expect a specific, helpful experience.

If you treat these two groups the same, you corrupt your data and your expectations. Design different welcomes, different cadences, and different success criteria for each.

What to do (practical)

Add a field: optin_type = consequential | intentional.
- Consequential: short value proof, remind why they’re here, set expectations, ask “why now?”, delay heavy promos or lead gen/sales activation for set periods of time.
- Intentional: deliver promised value immediately, reinforce topics and calibrate frequency.
  
  Build two welcome flows:
Report separately (open/click is not the goal; look at time-to-value and progression).

What “strategic data” actually means

Strategic data is anything that changes what you say or when you send it. If a field won’t alter the journey, you don’t need it.

The most underrated examples:

Motivation (“why now? or what best describes why you're here”): The real reason they showed up for whatever action they are taking e.g. pressure from leadership, a specific problem to fix, curiosity, research phase, a gift, or a time-bound outcome. This dictates cadence, proof points, and CTA strength.
Topic interest: What they want more of (e.g., deliverability vs copy vs strategy). This shapes your editorial calendar and which examples you use.
Cadence preference: Weekly, twice-monthly, launches only. This reduces attention debt and improves long-term engagement.
Context of entry: Where they came from and what was promised (newsletter vs 10% code vs webinar). This sets expectations and prevents tone mismatches.

B2C/D2C examples (use your voice here)

Gift vs self: If someone is buying as a gift, their “why” is different. You’ll prioritise reminders, delivery timelines, and reassurance content - not general product education.
Problem/goal at sign-up: For a hair-care brand, ask “What’s your biggest hair challenge right now?” (e.g., growth, breakage, colour-safe). You now know which before/after stories, routines, and timing windows to use.
Lead magnet with a point: Offer a mini email course or quick-start guide that naturally asks one genuine qualifier (e.g., “I’ve tried X and it didn’t work” vs “I’m brand new”). That one answer changes your next three emails.

B2B/SaaS examples (straight from your world)

Trial intent: “Why are you trying this tool?” (replacing an existing platform/board pressure to fix reporting/testing integrations / personal upskilling). Sales shouldn’t treat those the same; nor should marketing nurture.
Buying horizon: “Actively evaluating” vs “this quarter” vs “exploring.” The first gets proof + CTA; the last gets value cadence and softer timing.
Role & team context: A Head of Marketing with a two-person team needs different examples, templates and “doable this week” guidance than an Operations Director with budget and a cross-functional squad.

When to ask (and when not to)

The art is timing - ask the least you need now, then layer more later.

At entry (only what steers the next send):
- Intentional sign-ups: ask why now? and a one-click topic pick.
- Consequential sign-ups: keep it light; deliver the promised thing first, then ask one meaningful follow-up in the welcome.
Inside the welcome (days 2–10):
- Light “choose your own path” clicks (“More B2B examples / More D2C examples / Both”).
- Frequency nudge (“Weekly, twice-monthly, or launches only?”).
After first action (purchase/demo/attendance):
- B2C: routine length, concern, repurchase window, “is this for a gift?”
- B2B: main obstacle (budget/time/integration), tool stack, team size — only if it will change enablement.
At risk of disengagement:
- Offer snooze (30/60 days), topic swap, or lighter cadence instead of another hard CTA.

If a question won’t change the next step, don’t ask it. You can always use indirect signals (what people read, pages they view, support tickets raised) to infer interests without adding friction.

Using indirect data (when you can’t ask)

You won’t collect everything explicitly and you don’t need to.

Content consumption: People who repeatedly read deliverability posts are telling you what to send next.
Page patterns: Pricing/demo pages = higher intent; comparison pages = solution search; help docs = onboarding gaps.
Cross-team signals: Sales calls, service tickets, returns - these are gold for topic planning and for exclusions (“don’t send generic promos while there’s an open ticket”).

Your job is to translate signals into decisions: send now vs later, proof vs promo, include vs exclude.

How to use the data (the simple rules that change results)

Match message to motivation. “Board pressure to fix email performance” needs commercial proof and timelines; “learning the basics” needs primer content and practical wins.
Protect new relationships. New or consequential subscribers shouldn’t get thrown into heavy promos; finish orientation and earn that invisible second opt-in.
Exclude on purpose. In an active sales cycle? Don’t broadcast. In a service issue? Send helpful enablement. Cooling off? Reduce cadence, offer snooze.
Plan by proven interest. If deliverability consistently outperforms “tool tips” for your audience, that’s your editorial bias — not a hunch.

Common pitfalls (and how to avoid them)

Collecting trivia. If it won’t change what you send, it’s just noise.
Front-loading forms. Don’t interrogate too much!
Treating all sign-ups the same. Honour consequential vs intentional, or your metrics will lie to you.
Never closing the loop. If people tell you what they want and nothing changes, they’ll stop telling you.

Start small (practical first steps)

Add a single WHY question for intentional sign-ups and use the answer to branch the next two emails.
In your welcome, include a one-click topic pick and reflect it in the very next send.
Create one simple exclusion rule (e.g., protect new subscribers from promos for the first x days/weeks).
Review your last 90 days of content and identify the top two performer topics - bias your next month toward them.

Btw, I've written a full blog here on data collection strategy that explains all.

Progressive profiling

Progressive profiling is one of the most powerful (and underused) techniques in email marketing. It’s how you build a full picture of your audience over time - without overwhelming them or scaring them off with a 10-field form.

Instead of trying to collect everything at once, you gather small, purposeful pieces of information at different touchpoints in the customer journey. Each interaction adds another layer of context, allowing you to refine your message, timing, and offers with surgical precision.

Think of it like a conversation: You don’t ask someone’s full life story the moment you meet them, you ask the right questions as the relationship deepens.

Why progressive profiling matters for email

Most email programmes fail because they try to personalise without the data to do it. Progressive profiling solves that by letting you:

Build trust and context first. You earn the right to ask for more by giving value upfront.
Segment intelligently. You move from “everyone gets everything” to “this person gets exactly what’s relevant.”
Improve deliverability. More relevant content = higher engagement = better placement.
Trigger better automation. You can tailor flows based on what people reveal over time.
Keep data fresh. It’s easier to update fields organically than to rely on one static sign-up moment.

How progressive profiling works (in practice)

Progressive profiling has three layers:

The entry layer – what you ask right now
This is your “minimum viable data (MVD)” It should be just enough to deliver on the promise that got them there (e.g., a newsletter, discount, or resource).
→ Examples: Name, email, reason for signing up (“What’s your biggest challenge?”), or product interest.
The relationship layer – what you learn after they’ve engaged
Once they’ve interacted (clicked, purchased, read, replied, attended), they’re warmer — and far more willing to tell you more.
→ Examples: Frequency preferences, category interests, content format preference, company size (B2B), buying horizon.
The refinement layer – what you infer from behaviour
This is where you use automation logic to enrich profiles without asking directly.
→ Examples: Pages viewed, product categories browsed, purchase patterns, email engagement, or lifecycle stage.

The key is sequencing your data capture so every question you ask adds immediate value — both for you and the subscriber.

How to use progressive profiling in different contexts

For B2C & D2C marketers

Your goal: move from basic segmentation to intent-based personalisation.

Start simple:

At signup: “What brings you here today?” or “What are you looking for help with?”
→ Responses like “new skincare routine,” “gift ideas,” or “eco swaps” are data gold.
During first purchase: Ask “Was this a gift or for you?” or “What are you hoping this product helps with?”
In follow-up emails: Offer 1-click preference tags (“Show me more [eco swaps] / [gift sets] / [skincare tips]”).

Over time:

Use order history + content clicks to infer motivations (e.g. “self-care buyer” vs “gift shopper” vs “bulk buyer”).
Feed this back into flows: self-care buyers get replenishment reminders and education, gift buyers get seasonal campaigns and packaging offers.

Bonus tip: Ask questions that feel like conversation, not form fields. Think: “Tell us what kind of shopper you are"

For B2B marketers

Your goal: move from generic nurture to contextual journeys based on stage, intent, and need.

Start small:

At signup or content download: Ask one meaningful question —
“What’s the main thing you’re trying to improve right now?”
Options like “lead management,” “reporting visibility,” or “email automation” will tell you which pain to lead with.

Then, layer more:

After engagement (opened multiple resources, attended webinar, etc.):
→ Ask about team size, role type, or current tool stack (this helps route leads correctly).
During or after demo or trial: “How soon are you looking to implement?” or “Who else is involved in decision-making?”

Use signals:

If they keep reading strategy content, tag them “early-stage.”
If they start comparing tools, tag them “evaluation.”
This moves them between nurturing flows automatically — no manual sorting required.

Bonus tip: Every additional question should serve a clear decision point. If it won’t change who they hear from or what they get next, don’t ask it.

How progressive profiling fuels better email results

Smarter segmentation = better deliverability.
You’re sending more relevant content to smaller, more engaged groups — filters love that.
Contextual journeys = higher conversion.
You can tailor not just what you send, but when you send it, based on intent signals.
Reduced form friction = higher opt-ins.
Asking less upfront removes signup anxiety — people commit faster when they know you’ll “ask later.”
Live insight loop = more sustainable strategy.
You never need a “massive data cleanup” again — you’re always collecting and enriching as you go.

What most marketers get wrong

❌ They ask everything at once.
(If you wouldn’t answer it in one go, neither will your audience.)

❌ They never use what they collect.
(Don’t ask for “role” if every email looks the same to every role.)

❌ They ask too late.
(If you wait until someone’s disengaged, it’s too late to fix the journey.)

✅ Start small.
✅ Add questions naturally as the relationship deepens.
✅ Feed every answer back into segmentation, automation, and exclusion logic.

Using data to exclude (the lever most teams ignore)

Exclusions protect deliverability, sharpen relevance, and stop teaching inbox filters that you’re ignorable.

Read the full blog about exclusion strategies here.

Core exclusion rules (start here)

Provider remediation: if provider_mailbox = outlook and seed tests show poor placement → exclude from big promos; send small value-first segment while you fix.
Recent negative signals: engagement_composite < 20 or risk_disengage_at <= today → move to low-frequency value cadence; no promos for 30 days.
Sales conflict: deal_stage != x → suppress general marketing; switch to coordinated sales-enablement content.
New subscriber (split type of opt in) protection: if subscribed_at <= 14 days → exclude from promos; complete orientation first.
Seasonal customers: if customer_type = seasonal → awareness only; exclude from weekly campaigns.

Practical “keep/kill/snooze” triage (for disengaged pots)

Kill (too risky, low ROI): B2B leads 3–5 years cold with no activity; bounced once + never recovered; obvious job change, no replacement contact.
Snooze/Awareness: customers who purchase annually but never engage → keep in low-touch awareness; measure revenue impact, not opens.
Keep & re-orient: recently subscribed but quiet → send value-first reset, request topic choice, reduce frequency.

Signals & scoring that predict action (and inaction)

Opens alone stupid (I try to ignore them!). You want a composite that weights strong signals more than weak ones.

An example of a simple, robust Engagement Composite (0–100)

Weights (this is just an example; adapt to your business and what metrics matter to you):

Reply in last 30d: +35
Pricing/demo page view last 7d: +20
Tool comparison/use case content last 14d: +12
Click depth ≥ 2 meaningful links in last 14d: +10
Site sessions ≥ 2 in last 14d: +8
First-party event (webinar attended) last 30d: +8
Newsletter open (tracked reliably) last 14d: +3

Decay: subtract 15 if no meaningful events in 30d; subtract an additional 10 at 60d.

Tiers:

70–100: High intent → sales-aligned or strong CTA
40–69: Warm → nurture and value + soft CTA
20–39: Cooling → frequency reduction, value-only, re-orientation
0–19: At risk → snooze option, topic swap, or pause

B2C RFM-lite + behaviour

R (recency of purchase), F (frequency), M (spend quartile).
Add category affinity, price sensitivity, returns flag.
Trigger replenishment, winback, or VIP flows accordingly.

Intent surge flags (binary)

≥2 pricing/demo page views within 48 hours, or calculator used, or return visit within 24 hours plus case study view → mark intent_surge = true and branch content immediately.

Predicting inaction (attention debt)

Count consecutive no-engage sends. At 5, auto-switch cadence; at 8, offer snooze; at 12, move to dormant prep.

Start simple. Even one composite + two binary flags (“intent_surge”, “attention_debt”) outperforms opens/clicks.

The deliverability link (why this whole data conversation matters)

Deliverability isn’t “set SPF/DKIM/DMARC and done”. It’s the outcome of sending relevant email, at sensible cadence, to people who actually want it - consistently.

Smart data lets you:

Stop hammering invisible churn
Prime big sends through your most engaged cohorts first (filters reward early positives)
Separate mailbox providers and tune volume/format
Time message type to intent (value first at risk, CTA when hot)
Prove (to SLT) that exclusions and cadence control increase revenue per 1,000 emails, even if total volume drops

“We don’t have enough data” — fix it without stalling

Draw a line in the sand: turn on smarter capture now (don’t wait to backfill the past).
Instrument easy signals: click-to-tag; topic beacons; a single “why now?” in the welcome.
Exploit what you already have: acquisition source, mailbox provider, device, region, purchase history, support tickets—they’re already in your systems.
Micro-campaigns: once a quarter, send a two-question “Help us help you” poll to active segments only.
Reply mining: standardise labels; write to fields; summarise monthly to content/sales.

Measuring what matters (exec-friendly)

Your SLT doesn’t care about open rates. Give them risk, impact, and money.

Placement → outcome: track inbox/spam (via seeds/tests) by provider alongside revenue/pipeline per 1,000 recipients by provider.
Exclusion ROI: compare last quarter’s campaigns with vs without the exclusion framework; show lift in revenue per 1k and fall in spam complaints.
Time to value: days from sign-up to first meaningful action; your data strategy should shorten this.
Message fit: topic-level conversion by segment; kill low performers.
Prevented loss: estimate avoided revenue loss from provider remediation (e.g., Microsoft spam reduced from 100% → 20% over 6 months; pipeline regained).
Board slide: “Volume down 22%, revenue per 1,000 up 31%, spam complaints –65%, Outlook inbox placement +48 pts.”

Advanced plays (less talked about, very effective)

Opt-in heat score:
- Intentional +2; completed quiz/course +1; reply +3; consequential +0; promo-only entry −1.
- Use it to set starting cadence and promo eligibility.
“Why now?” drives the first 14 days:
- Map answers to journeys (e.g., “migrating tools”, “board pressure”, “need quick win”, “learning only”). Each gets different proof, different CTA, different rhythm.
Topic telemetry:
- Tag every link with a topic code (e.g., topic=deliverability/copy/strategy/tools). Roll up engagement by segment to decide your editorial calendar based on actual interest, not guesses.
No-send windows per segment:
- Identify dead zones by cohort (e.g., enterprise IT never engages Fri PM–Mon AM). Codify no_send_windows and enforce them in scheduling logic.
Snooze logic:
- One-click “Pause me for 30 days.” Saves relationships and improves reputation. Store no_send_until and honour it.
Kill criteria (decide once, automate):
- Example B2B: no_click_365d AND no_reply_365d AND not_customer AND (bounced_soft_once OR role_unknown) → archive/delete.
- Example B2C: no_purchase_18m AND no_click_12m AND returns=0 AND discount_only=true → archive.
Provider-aware throttling:
- Lead with Gmail-engaged cohort to earn early positives; roll to Outlook next; Yahoo last. Back-off rules if the complaint rate spikes.
Channel-conflict guardrails:
- If deal_stage active or cs_ticket_open = true, halt promos; send helpful enablement or service updates only.
Exclusion-first cadencing:
- Cadence isn’t “weekly vs monthly”. It’s “what’s safe and valuable for this person this week”. Use engagement_composite and optin_heat to choose weekly/fortnightly/hold.

When in doubt, ask this

“Will this data point change what I send or when I send it?”

If no → don’t collect it.
If yes → collect it and automate the change.

More support when it comes to email:

You’ve got two options:

Do it yourself:

Join upcoming masterclasses here →
They’re CPD-accredited, packed with ungooglable insights, and include my full six-step deliverability audit template.

Read my newsletter to get as much info on all things email →
RE:markable is the weekly email about emails. Dropping the latest email marketing news, updates, insights, free resources, upcoming masterclasses, webinars, and of course, a little inbox mischief.

Work with me:
If you want me to design your schema, implement the collection plan, wire the automations/exclusions, and tie everything to deliverability and impact, I can embed with your team and build it properly.

Start with a conversation →

Like this blog? You'll love RE:markable