12/2025

The Ultimate Checklist for a Healthy Email Ecosystem

Before you dig in, why don't you get access to RE:markable

RE:markable is the weekly email about emails. Dropping the latest email marketing news, updates, insights, free resources, upcoming masterclasses, webinars, and of course, a little inbox mischief.

Subscribe to RE:markable

If your email strategy begins and ends with a campaign calendar (whether it’s neat and colour-coded or not), it’s not a strategy… it’s chaos.

I’m not saying that to make you feel bad, the narrative online around email marketing tends to focus on the “doing” of email (writing, designing, hitting send) rather than the entire ecosystem required for email to actually work.

An email ecosystem is exactly what it sounds like. It’s everything your email marketing needs to thrive rather than simply survive: data, systems, people, strategy, deliverability, content, and messaging.

It’s everything that drives long-term performance, not quick wins.

This isn’t about how to write a good email; it’s about building a strong foundation so every email has a chance of doing what it’s supposed to do.

Here’s the ultimate checklist for a healthy email ecosystem.

The four pillars of a healthy email ecosystem: The PPPP™ Framework

If you’ve read any of my content before, you’ve probably seen me talk about The PPPP™ Framework.

It might sound like just another email marketing template or gimmick (yawn), but it’s actually a systemic, layered approach to email that covers key areas of how email works as an operational, data-led, human-centric growth function.

Pillar 1: Systems (your infrastructure)

Your tech stack is the backbone and foundation of your email ecosystem.

It includes your CRM, ESP, website, and any third-party tools, form builders, data pools, and everything that operationalises your strategy.

If you’re using something to collect, connect, activate, or automate your data, it’s under this umbrella.

The issue is usually that the foundation is, for all intents and purposes, built on sand. I’m talking CRM being used as a tool rather than as a business function, overlapping data, rogue workflows, and poor authentication and segmentation.

Here’s what you should be avoiding with your systems:

Lack of integration
Not scalable or future-proofed
Full of workarounds and duct-tape fixes

If it’s holding you back instead of unlocking progress, there’s a problem that needs to be fixed!

Instead, you should focus on making sure that your:

Automation and workflows are mapped logically (no overlap or rogue workflows)
CRM is a business function, not a tool
Data flows in both directions (e.g., CRM ↔ website ↔ sales tools ↔ analytics)
Authentication is set up properly, including SPF, DKIM, DMARC, and BIMI
Segmentation and tagging structure are in place and documented
Automation isn’t redundant and running in the background, including “ghost workflows”
Reporting dashboards reflect outcomes, not vanity metrics

Key takeaway: Operational alignment and visibility are foundational to your email marketing success, and no amount of creativity or testing will save your strategy without fixing these areas first.

Goal: Your system is clean, connected, and supporting your strategy (not working against it).

Pillar 2: Strategy (your why & who)

“Okay,” you say whilst reading, “we might not have nailed the systems part, but we already have a content calendar, decent automations, and a dashboard.”

Well, yes, and that’s not bad! But what you really need is:

A clear reason why email exists in your business (all elements of marketing need a purpose, after all)
Alignment with wider goals, teams, and journeys
Clarity on mindset, ownership, purpose, and performance

Strategy is your email’s reason for existing. Without one, you can’t align your strategy with your overall business goals, which is where the issues begin to stack up.

Ask yourself:

What is the role of email in our business? Who owns it?
How does email support the wider customer journey?
Are we tracking campaign performance or strategic impact?

Every single email should be linked to a business goal or audience need, which means that documenting each lifecycle journey is essential, from awareness all the way down to retention and re-engagement.

Avoid the “email everyone” mentality and focus on aligning your sales, marketing, and services on messaging, frequency, and audience segments.

Oh and do not assume your audience remembers who you are, why they signed up, or what they expected from you. A lot of the time, people joined months ago, downloaded something once, bought from you briefly, or opened an email while distracted. Unless you show up with intention and consistency, they forget - quickly.

Goal: Your email activity aligns with strategy, not schedule.

Pillar 3: Data (your foundation)

If your data feels like a liability, it’s usually because something underneath it is broken.

Strong email programmes rely on clean, structured, purposeful data that deepens over time.

You need to:

Collect motivational and intent-based data, not just demographics
Distinguish consequential vs intentional opt-ins
Implement progressive profiling so your data becomes smarter as people engage
Maintain suppression lists and exclusion logic
Make data usable across teams — not trapped in silos
Validate your data regularly (ZeroBounce etc.)
Measure disengagement patterns, not only engagement peaks

Consequential opt-ins (e.g., downloads, checkouts, webinar signups) carry low intent.
Intentional opt-ins carry significantly higher permission and better engagement.

A healthy ecosystem recognises this difference and adjusts frequency, messaging, and expectations accordingly.

And don’t forget invisible permission - the unwritten expectation that your emails will meet the value someone thought they were signing up for. Break invisible permission (by changing tone, frequency, purpose, or showing up unpredictably), and engagement will collapse before you notice. Inbox providers will notice much sooner.

Goal: Data drives decisions, segmentation, timing, and deliverability

Pillar 4: People (your process & skills)

Systems and data are useless without people who understand how to operate them.

Ask yourself:

Is there a clear internal owner of CRM/email strategy?
Do teams understand deliverability, consent, and compliance?
Is everyone trained properly on the CRM and ESP?
Are sales, service, and marketing aligned on communication?
Are workflows, naming conventions, and SOPs documented?
Do you review performance collaboratively (not in silos)?

If people don’t know how to contribute, what good looks like, or how decisions are made, nothing will run smoothly.

And don’t assume leadership understands how email works. Most don’t. They see a newsletter. You see infrastructure, permission frameworks, behavioural signals, attribution, and a whole ecosystem holding the business up behind the scenes. Educating upwards is part of maintaining ecosystem health.

Goal: Your people know how to use the tools and make confident, informed decisions.

The red flags of an unhealthy email ecosystem

If you’re feeling slightly called out or unsure whether your ecosystem is in good shape, here are the signs something isn’t right:

Your CRM & ESP don’t talk to each other
No one cleans the data and there is no data strategy
Your automations haven’t been touched in over a year
Email is a “hand-me-down” channel with no owner
You’re still emailing the entire list
You have an email plan — not an email strategy
You measure success using opens and clicks alone
You don’t track spam complaints
Deliverability is a mystery (or you assume your ESP will tell you)
You can’t quantify email’s impact on revenue, leads, or conversions

The good news: Every single one of these is fixable.

Quick wins to improve your email health

Sometimes you need a few quick fixes to build on and gain some momentum before building your ecosystem from the ground up.

Here are a few things you can do.

Validate your list: Remove invalid emails and focus on email hygiene to keep your sender reputation high and have metrics that reflect engaged, active users.
Audit your automations and flows: Systematically review your current automations and triggered flows to clarify their sequence, and insert exclusions for segments to avoid overlapping messages.
Run a deliverability test and audit: Read our full guide to email deliverability, or find out the ins and outs of B2C & D2C email deliverability at my masterclass (or keep an eye out for future masterclasses).
Make unsubscribing easier: It sounds counterintuitive, but making 1-click opt-outs will keep complaints low and trust higher.

Advanced optimisation for mature ecosystems

If your basics are already ticking along healthily, then you can opt for some more advanced optimisation.

Engagement scoring and predictive signals: Implement engagement scoring to dive deeper into each subscriber in terms of opens, clicks, replies, web visits, and purchase signals. Proactively adapt your messaging, particularly when you have historical behaviour to forecast with.
Topic telemetry (tracking interests via behaviour): Track what people are clicking, which pages they’re browsing, which products they view, and recommend more relevant content and topics to match.
Snooze logic and send-window optimisation: Give segments the ability to take a break without fully unsubscribing (e.g., allowing them to pause or snooze contacts based on low engagement). Send-window optimisation can be used to send emails when people are most likely to open and act.
Exclusion triggers based on real-time sales interactions: Have marketing and sales working in tandem so that people aren’t receiving messaging not aligned with their lifecycle stage. Set up key lifecycle stages in your CRM with rules on your automation platform to keep things running smoothly.
Impact measurement beyond clicks: Clicks aren’t the best indicator of success, so you need to go deeper to get to the real value. Opt for metrics that match your objectives rather than surface-level metrics, whether it’s time to value or message fit.

Your CRM is really the place where all of the elements of your ecosystem come together, which means you need clean data flowing into your CRM to report on the full journey properly.
Use your CRM as a business function, not a tool, to close the loop. Feed the insights from it back into your strategy to adapt and evolve!

Email health = alignment, clarity & consistency

Email health isn’t about sending fewer or prettier emails. It’s about having a connected stream that makes up your email ecosystem, backed by a solid strategy and consistent, clean, clear data.

The best email strategies aren’t louder or full of hacks and templates; they’re smarter, and they’re intentional.

Build a solid foundation by focusing on each element and building from the ground up, and your emails will thrive across all areas rather than just “getting by” as you go.

If your email ecosystem feels messy or disconnected, that’s exactly what I help fix.

I work with B2B teams to transform email and CRM from chaos into clarity — book an audit or workshop and start building a system that actually works.

Like this blog? You'll love RE:markable