The Science of Inbox and Email Attention
Before you dig in, why don't you get access to RE:markable
RE:markable is the weekly email about emails. Dropping the latest email marketing news, updates, insights, free resources, upcoming masterclasses, webinars, and of course, a little inbox mischief.
Attention isn’t what you think it is
When your emails land in an inbox, you’re not fighting for attention; you’re fighting for relevance, mental availability, and permission.
Attention isn’t scarce but it’s selective.
And inbox behaviour has changed so dramatically over the last few years that most email marketers are operating with assumptions that no longer reflect how people actually process email.
In the era of “AI everywhere you look”, answers are instant, information is abundant, and inboxes are overflowing. Email is no longer the default learning space it used to be. People aren’t scrolling their inbox hoping to be inspired!
And yet, many marketers still behave as though attention is something they can capture by shouting louder, sending more, or tweaking the subject line one more time.
It doesn’t work like that, not anymore.
So here’s the question we’re exploring today:
Why do people disengage and how do you design for real attention, even if your emails aren’t opened?
Let’s get into the neuroscience, the psychology, and the behavioural reality of how attention works in an inbox.
1. Inbox attention is neurological, not emotional
People don’t give attention to the way marketers imagine they do. They don’t open email thoughtfully, t hey don’t evaluate everything consciously.
Most inbox behaviour is fast, automatic, heuristic, and subconscious. Here’s what the brain is doing the moment someone opens their inbox:
Cognitive load: the brain cuts corners fast
Our brain is pretty busy at any given moment, so mental shortcuts (sometimes referred to as heuristics) are often used subconsciously to cut through the crap.
They arrive with fatigue, stress, pressure, distraction, deadlines - a brain already full.
In the inbox, that means that anything remotely resembling clutter is immediately ignored and mentally filtered out in favour of clear relevance signals — things that feel urgent or relevant will always win out.
-
Anything that looks like “work” gets deprioritised
-
Anything that feels cluttered gets ignored
-
Anything that doesn’t match their immediate purpose is filtered out
-
Anything irrelevant is auto-dismissed without a single thought
This isn’t disinterest though, but more the brain protecting itself from overload.
Inbox triage: the brain prioritises states, not senders
I’d say just like triage at the GPs works, but you don’t have to deal with scrambling to secure an appointment by battling your GP’s receptionist at 8 am on the dot.
Similarly, though, our brain does triage our inboxes, scanning sender names, the context, and also considering our state of mind to decide if an email is a priority.
People triage their inbox based on their current mode, not your marketing goals:
-
“What do I need to reply to?”
-
"What answers a question or helps me with that thing that I was just thinking about?"
-
"What do I know I should look at?"
-
“What’s urgent?”
-
“What can I delete or clear out?”
-
“What helps me feel in control?”
Your email is judged against their emotional and cognitive state, not against your subject line or campaign objectives.
A brilliant email sent into the wrong mental state will be ignored. A mediocre email sent into the right mental state will get attention.
Context > creativity.
Predictive coding: the brain guesses before it looks
Have you ever taken half a second to scan your inbox and immediately skipped or deleted an email because you felt like you already knew what it was?
That’s what predictive coding is! We’re making fast assumptions because we feel like we’ve probably already seen it before.
Predictive coding is the brain’s favourite trick: “If I think I know what this is, I won’t spend energy on it.”
This is why people ignore emails they’ve “seen before”, even if the content inside is completely different.
And when all the emails look similar - guess what happens!? We predictive code EVERYTHING
If your emails:
-
Look the same
-
Sound the same
-
Follow the same pattern
-
Repeat the same structure
…their brain deletes them without reading.
Emotional association: attention is based on memory, not marketing
It’s a simple process, really! We see an email from a brand we trust or enjoy, and we open it. We’re relying on our past experiences with a brand to shape our future behaviour towards it.
Subject lines become secondary to the relationship memory because if we’ve previously found a brand’s emails to be useful or engaging, they’ll automatically be viewed under a positive lens, regardless.
People’s inbox behaviour is shaped by:
-
past experiences with your brand,
-
the usefulness of your previous emails,
-
whether you’ve ever annoyed them,
-
the feeling your name creates,
-
the trust you’ve built (or broken).
This is why subject lines matter far less than marketers believe. The name in the inbox is the real subject line.
If it’s negative, there is a high chance they scroll past forever.
Pattern recognition & novelty: attention spikes when patterns break
We get used to what we can expect from our inboxes pretty quickly, which means that anything clashing with that is immediately more engaging.
Anything predictable gets mentally collapsed.
Novelty, not noise, is what triggers attention.
It’s called pattern interruption. Unexpected tone, curiosity, humour… anything we’re not anticipating is something our brains immediately take notice of.
Pattern interruption works because it forces the brain to stop, re-evaluate, and pay attention.
It means:
-
unexpected tone
-
human language
-
surprising value
-
a different format
-
something that doesn’t match your “usual” pattern in a good way
Novelty is not louder (no caps please)
Novelty is different.
Inbox attention is neurological. You’re not competing for “eyes”, you’re competing for a place in someone’s mental model.
2. The purpose problem: People don’t go to their inbox to buy (only sometimes)
We don’t go to our inboxes for fun, and checking our emails isn’t a leisure activity.
And here’s something most marketers struggle to accept:
- People do not go to their inbox to shop
- They go to their inbox to complete tasks
The inbox is a purpose-driven environment. Email is a functional environment, not a browsing environment.
We’ve subscribed to emails for a multitude of reasons: discount codes, trials, information-gathering, education, and entertainment.
Which means that when we’re opening our inbox, it’s to check, clear, respond, find information, or fix problems… rarely to browse or buy.
Unless you're actively searching for that promo code you saw last week! Or you remember that a brand sends you so many pushy promo's they'll defo be a code for when you needto buy.
Unfortunately, a lot of email marketers are hardwired to focus on the latter, which means that their emails are automatically being funnelled out.
People enter inbox mode in four ways:
- Task mode: Responding, organising, clearing, managing logistics.
- Reward mode: Personal updates, news, dopamine hits from positive notifications.
- Utility mode: Searching for discount codes, tracking deliveries, and event info.
- Avoidance mode: Clearing the inbox to feel productive (relatable… we’ve all been there!)
But in B2B, there’s a fifth mode that changes everything:
-
Learning (or information-gathering) mode: Researching, comparing tools, gathering ideas, reading educational content, filling knowledge gaps, or preparing for internal conversations. This is where value-first content performs best - but only if your email respects the cognitive load people are already under.
When email marketers send emails assuming readers are in buying mode, they’re not aligned with real inbox psychology.
Your emails aren’t being ignored because people don’t care. They’re ignored because they aren’t meeting the reader where they are, and for their current state of mind.
3. The data dimension: Why consequential opt-ins are destroying attention
Not all email sign-ups are created equal.
Most of us will, at some point (or many points), sign up for emails to get discounts, sign up for events, download gated content, or fill out an enquiry form.
This isn’t inherently bad, but it does mean that our sign-up was contingent on receiving something in the short term, making us prone to attention decay, as we never intended to build a long-term inbox relationship.
Which means that you have a rather sizeable portion of your subscribers creating false signals that wreak havoc on your metrics because they’re engaging once and then ghosting.
Before you know it, you’re dealing with rapid disengagement and negative reputation signals, which eventually flush your deliverability swiftly down the toilet.
Let me be clear, here: lack of interest isn’t about bad emails; it’s about misaligned expectations.
That’s why you want to prioritise intentional opt-ins - signing up for newsletters, educational flows, value-first sign-ups, because they sustain attention for longer, because the person not only expects your content, they genuinely want it.
Intentional = long-term attention
Consequential = one-time transaction
TL;DR: You can’t force attention from people who never opted in to give it, you can only earn it from those who chose to engage in the first place.
You can learn what to do with consequential opt-ins and how to grow their attention in this blog here.
4. The science of inbox habits: Why attention decays without novelty and consistency
- Attention decays when:
- emails look the same
- tone is predictable
- content is repetitive
- cadence is chaotic
- the value is unclear
- psychological needs are unmet
1. Novelty (pattern interruption)
2. Consistency (trust, reliability, safety)
Most brands and businesses fail at both. They either bombard people with the same content over and over…
or disappear for weeks at a time and then reappear loudly.
Neither pattern sustains attention!
The Zeigarnik Effect: unfinished ideas create sustained attention
Our brains are wired to hold onto incomplete tasks far longer than completed ones.
It’s a cognitive tension loop: when something feels “unfinished”, the mind keeps it active, waiting for resolution. Email marketers massively underestimate how powerful this is.
This is why multi-part content, series, and progressive narratives perform so well. When you create an open loop - a question, a cliffhanger, a promise of something coming next, you extend the lifespan of attention far beyond the moment of the send. You’re not relying on curiosity alone; you’re leveraging a neurological mechanism that nudges the reader back towards closure.
Story threads, multi-step journeys, guided sequences, even simple “Part 1 → Part 2 → Part 3” structures keep subscribers more engaged for longer because their brain remembers that something isn’t finished yet. Even if they don’t open every instalment, the thread of continuity builds familiarity and anticipation.
People want resolution, they’re wired for it and you can design for it intentionally.
The memory effect: ignored emails still work
One of the biggest mindset shifts email marketers need is this: an unopened email isn’t a failed email.
When someone scrolls past your message, their brain still registers multiple micro-signals:
-
they recognise your sender name
-
they recall previous experiences with your emails
-
they absorb your tone and positioning subconsciously
-
they register that you are consistently present
-
they categorise you as familiar, safe, or useful
Email isn’t only a conversion channel - it is a impact channel.
It shapes brand recall, builds mental availability and it reinforces positioning long before someone is ready to act.
This matters because in B2B, 95% of your audience isn’t ready to buy right now. They’re not supposed to click every email. They’re supposed to remember you until the moment they are ready and consistency trains that memory far more than sporadic “big” campaigns ever will.
When you redefine attention as “being remembered” rather than “being clicked”, everything about how you measure success changes. You stop chasing reactions and start designing relationships.
Email becomes a long-term asset, not a short-term performance contest!!
6. How to reclaim attention (without manipulation or gimmicks)
Lean into the science of attention!
Use behavioural data to match message to moment
Reclaiming attention starts by understanding the psychological mode someone is likely in when your email lands. People move between task, utility, reward, avoidance, and (in B2B) learning mode. Each mode has different cognitive bandwidth and different expectations. If someone is in task mode, they want clarity and utility. If they’re in learning mode, deeper educational content will land. If they’re in reward mode, stories and emotion resonate. When emails assume buying mode, but the reader is nowhere near it, the message collapses instantly. Behavioural data is your cue for what someone is ready to receive.
Stop assuming people are in buying mode
Most engagement issues come from misaligned intent. Email marketers write as though every subscriber is waiting to purchase, when in reality people open their inbox to complete tasks, find information, or clear notifications. Buying mode is the exception, not the norm. When you design emails for a psychological state your reader isn’t in, attention is lost — not because your content is bad, but because it’s mistimed.
Speak like a human - not a marketer
Human tone cuts through cognitive clutter. People scan for relevance, emotional cues, and clarity, not polished “brand voice” statements that survived seven rounds of approval. If your email sounds like a template or a corporate press release, the brain dismisses it before the reader even gets to your point. Human tone lowers resistance, increases processing fluency, and makes your emails feel safe and familiar.
Use curiosity and delight but please not pressure
Curiosity works because it relaxes the brain and invites exploration. Pressure does the opposite: it increases cognitive load and shuts attention down. You don’t need tricks or bait — simply create gentle open loops, intriguing angles, unexpected phrasing, or narrative breadcrumbs that give the reader a reason to lean in. Delight is a far more durable attention tool than urgency.
Design for scanning, not reading
People don’t read emails, they skim them. Attention comes from reducing cognitive effort: clear hierarchy, meaningful subheads, whitespace, and one idea per scroll. Your job is to make the “why should I care?” immediately obvious. When an email feels visually structured and cognitively light, engagement rises because the person doesn’t have to work to understand it.
Respect cognitive context and emotional state
Attention is contextual. Someone in avoidance mode won’t engage with long-form content. Someone who is fatigued won’t respond well to promotions. Someone cooling off won’t appreciate increased volume. Every inbox session is shaped by emotional load, competing priorities, and mental bandwidth. When your content doesn’t match the reader’s state, it gets ignored — even if it’s brilliant.
Slow down for low-intent or cooling segments
Sometimes the most strategic thing you can do is send less. When someone is overwhelmed or drifting, more email erodes trust. Space creates relief; relief creates psychological safety; psychological safety creates renewed attention. This is one of the most misunderstood, yet most powerful, drivers of sustainable engagement.
Optimise your entry points for intentional attention
Accidental sign-ups create accidental attention. Intentional sign-ups create durable attention. If your list is built on discounts, freebies, checkbox opt-ins, or one-off downloads, engagement will naturally decay. Value-led entry points — newsletters, mini-courses, educational resources — attract people who want to hear from you. That single decision improves every downstream metric you care about.
The real goal: relevance to the reader’s internal state
Reclaiming attention isn’t about being louder, bolder, or more frequent. It’s about becoming aligned with the psychological, emotional, and contextual state your reader is actually in. When you honour that, engagement stops being something you chase and becomes something that emerges naturally.
7. Attention isn’t captured, it’s earned
Attention isn’t something you take from people. It’s something they choose to give you.People will give attention when you are relevant, when you are consistent, when you genuinely help them, when you reduce cognitive load rather than increasing it, and when you respect the environment you’re entering. The inbox is intimate and personal, but it’s overloaded. When you show up in a way that honours that space, attention becomes a natural byproduct.
Most importantly, attention is earned when you honour the promise you made at the point of sign-up. If someone joins your list because they want help, guidance, clarity, or a particular type of content, your emails should reinforce, not betray, that expectation. When the promise is broken, attention collapses immediately.
Your goal is not to get people to read every email or buy straight away!! Your goal is to get people to remember you.
Because the moment they are ready to act, whether that’s buying, booking, returning, subscribing, or reaching out, their brain retrieves the brands and businesses or names held most clearly in memory. That retrieval moment is the entire commercial value of attention. And email, more than any other channel, builds that memory through consistent presence, tone, positioning, and relevance.
This is the real science of attention. Not squeezing opens up to burnt-out subscribers. Just human psychology, relevance, timing, and trust.
If you want to build emails that work with human behaviour rather than fight against it, that’s exactly what I help teams do. I work with marketers and leadership to design email ecosystems grounded in:
- attention science
- audience behaviour
- strategic journeys
- trust and deliverability
- real-world decision-making
👉 Book a free consultation with me
👉 Join one of my upcoming masterclasses
Attention isn’t magic! It’s mechanics, psychology and a bucket load of trust.
And all three can be rebuilt!
Like this blog? You'll love RE:markable
RE:markable is the weekly email about emails. Dropping the latest email marketing news, updates, insights, free resources, upcoming masterclasses, webinars, and of course, a little inbox mischief.